wpr-dpi-underly-11162026
[00:00:00] It’s Wisconsin Today. I’m Kate Archer Kent. And I’m Rob Ferrett. The Wisconsin Department of Public Instruction is proposing a major overhaul for how the state funds its public schools. On Friday, the department released its two-year budget request for 2027 to 2029. That includes roughly $2.75 billion in new funding for K-12 schools.
It comes as many school districts around the state have increasingly relied on referendums and local ballots to [00:00:30] supplement their funding, and as Democrats take full control of state government in January. To talk more about her department’s budget proposal, State Superintendent of Public Instruction Jill Underly joins us now.
Welcome back to the program. Hey, great to be here. Good morning. So you’re, this is stage one, of course, of the budget process. You’re requesting roughly $2.75 billion in new money for K-12 schools over the next two years. You’ve asked for big increases before, but lawmakers had cut [00:01:00] them back. Why do you think this time might be different?
Well, I think we’re really at an inflection point, and it’s, uh, also a historic opportunity. Um, we’ve… We’re beyond, um, beyond time to fix the broken school funding formula. Um, as everybody knows, our districts are continually going to operational referendum, and so my job is to, is to put enough money into the system through my budget requests and advoc- for our kids, [00:01:30] and the job of the legislature is to fund our schools.
So hopefully they will take that request seriously. And in announcing the request, you said it’s time to fix the formula. It’s time to put school referendums out of business. Can you talk more about what problem are you trying to solve here with this plan, and how does it solve it? Yeah. Absolutely. So we can’t keep asking local communities to solve a statewide funding problem, and they’re doing this, you know, through referendum.
And we need a system that reflects the actual costs [00:02:00] of educating students and the needs of our classrooms today. Um, and, and state funding revenue limits, um, they have not kept pace with inflation, and so that’s what we see. You know, the system that has been in place, especially in the past 15 years, has not been predictable or reliable and not indexed to inflation, and that’s what this budget, um, fixes.
And, and this proposal updates the formula to recognize the cost of what [00:02:30] it takes to educate students today and build more funding into the base so districts have that, um, that predictability and that sustainable resources rather than relying on one-time adjustments. And so as you build more funding into the base in- through this proposal- Mm-hmm
it doesn’t say where more than $2 billion will come from. I mean, even with the state surplus, most of the proposed dollars would be ongoing costs. Can the state afford- Sure … this plan? Well, I, I certainly [00:03:00] think so. Um, it’s the job of the legislature really to find the money. Um, you know, over the past years, um, when they’ve had a priority, which budgets are all about, they find the money for that.
And it’s really, it’s really time that public education becomes the priority again. Um, the state simply just needs to take greater responsibility for funding our public schools so that the local property taxpayer isn’t continually asked to make up the difference, because that’s what we’re seeing- Um, [00:03:30] is 90% of districts have been gone to referendum over the past nine years.
Um, and this budget doesn’t increase statewide property tax levy. So I mean, we need to put the responsibility back on the state, um, really reduce the reliance on operating referendums. Um, and really it’s, again, it’s about priorities, and it’s, this is really a serious priority for the state legislature.
They’ll find the money for it. Well, if revenue limits go up and state aid also goes up, [00:04:00] then property taxes could stay steady, but then you are counting on more state aid to kinda neutralize property tax increases here in this proposal. Mm-hmm. Right. Yeah, I absolutely am. I think we need to just kind of think back to all the times, um, the legislature has tried to prioritize different things.
When they’re, uh, when they’re lowering, um, or w- when they’re giving a tax, um, credit, for example, or, um, lowering taxes [00:04:30] on corporations or, or whatever, um, we’re not asking them where that money’s coming from, right? They figure it out. If that’s their priority, they figure it out, and they take it from other places if they have to.
And, and that’s really what’s been happening to public schools over the past 15-plus years, is that other priorities have been taking money from public schools. And what we wanna do is change that, bring the priority back to public education, invest in our students. Um, we know that when we [00:05:00] invest in our public schools, we’re gonna have a stronger Wisconsin in the long run.
When we have healthy schools, we will have a healthy economy. Um, and, um, and it’s, you know, elections, we’ve heard this before, have consequences, and it seems to me that this new legislature was listening to the voters, and the voters want, um, they want strong public schools. And so I’m, I’m excited to see what they do with it.
So what about the partial veto by Governor Evers in 2023 that authorized districts to [00:05:30] raise property taxes to boost their budgets through the year ’24, ’25? Do your budget proposals increases in the property tax levy limit replace that 400-year partial veto? So I think that’s a different, that’s a different topic.
Okay. ‘Cause really all that did was give school districts the ability to, um, raise the revenue limits. And what my budget is telling, um, the state to do instead is to focus on fixing the [00:06:00] funding formula, put more money in to the funding formula so that school districts don’t have to raise the taxes on their, on their taxpayers.
So it’s, again, it’s just, you know, keeping students at the center. Um, the formula is really a mechanism. Um, and the way that we’re able to do this is we have to put money into the formula. We haven’t been. We haven’t been meeting inflationary increases even, and that’s why we’ve seen, um, districts having to, you know, either levy more [00:06:30] or go to referendum more.
And what the veto did was just allowed school districts to levy more. Very quickly before we have to let you go, Governor-elect David Crowley proposes a state budget, of course, not DPI. This is your proposal here. Have you talked with his team already? Yes. Oh, yeah. Um, I, I know David, uh, fairly well and, and his team, so, um, just looking forward to continually talking about this and, and making sure that, um, you know, this is…
Again, it’s just a fundamental shift in how Wisconsin funds our public [00:07:00] schools, and, um, so I’m excited to, to advocate and continue to advocate for what, what they need and, and that’s what I’ll continue to do. Superintendent Underly, thank you for joining us. Okay. Appreciate it very much. Thank you so much, Kate.
Jill Underly is the Wisconsin State Superintendent of Public Instruction. That’s the state’s top elected education official.
Now for some context about the history and politics around school funding in Wisconsin, we have Alan Borsuk, senior fellow in law and public policy at Marquette University [00:07:30] Law School.
Alan, welcome back. Glad to be here. We just heard from the state superintendent about her vision for the future of school funding. What stands out to you about what you heard? Well, she’s certainly right that it’s a different day. The tables have been turned in a real big way in the legislature. Um, this proposal is, uh, swinging for the fences, and they, I don’t think they’re gonna hit home runs on every aspect that what they’re asking.
There’s [00:08:00] certainly gonna be more money for public school. The governor elect campaigned on a promise of fully funding public school, but what that means is a little uncertain. But there’s lots of other things coming up, too. Uh, universities, uh, uh, health needs, uh, the, the correctional system. Uh, the, the governor elect has made a priority, wants to do something about housing.
The list goes on. And so the competition for money is gonna be intense. The demand for [00:08:30] increases, the request for increases is gonna exceed what’s possible. So I don’t think you- they’re gonna get as far as, as they’re, uh, seeking to go, but there’s gonna be change. I mean, it’s a whole different dynamic in the legislature now.
Now, you’ve followed and reported on Mil- Milwaukee Public Schools for decades, the state’s largest district. What would this proposal mean for Milwaukee schools in particular, and for the state’s private school choice programs? [00:09:00] Well, I’m glad you added the last phrase there ’cause that’s an important question.
And in the DPI material that were, uh, released on Friday, there’s really no mention of the private school and, and the charter school. A, a brief mention of the charter school. Um, and in the city of Milwaukee, um, more than 50% of the fully funded, the publicly funded kids going to, uh, going to school in the city of Milwaukee [00:09:30] are in those programs and not in Milwaukee public school.
We just crossed the 50% line, uh, for MPS this year for the first time. So you can’t really talk about Milwaukee education, and that is, I often refer to Milwaukee as the state capital of education issues. Um, y- you can’t talk about Milwaukee without talking about all the sectors. So what’s gonna happen with the voucher program and the charter school open enrollment?
A really good question. [00:10:00] Open question there. And, and I- Yeah. I wanna just stop here for a moment and look at that history of school funding formula. You know, there is a long history of how the current funding formula came to be, and one of those key moments was 1993 when the state tried to curb the rising property taxes by limiting how much a district could raise through general state aid and, and local property taxes.
Uh, those limits were supposed to expire but were made permanent. What happened? [00:10:30] What happened? Gridlock, I think is the simple answer. No one’s ever come up with a successful strategy to change the, the overall state funding formula since 1993, and some of the things that were locked in at that time, like inequities between public school districts, some of which spent more money and some of which spent less money, are still having an impact to this day more than 30 years later.
There was an effort to change the state funding formula in 2003, and it [00:11:00] went nowhere. There was a governor’s… There, there was a, a state legislature, a blue ribbon task force in 2017, and it went nowhere. Every proposal for changing the formula has gone nowhere. Will this one be different? Uh, the, the, the I’m, I’m kinda dubious of that, ’cause the resistance has been so great to the fundamental s- uh, structure of revenue caps and so on continues to this day, even with some, uh, built-in, uh, I’d even say [00:11:30] weirdnesses and especially inequities.
Hmm. Alan, thank you so much for joining us. Appreciate it. Glad to be here. Alan Borsuk is a senior fellow in law and public policy at Marquette University Law School. Earlier, we heard from the state’s top elected education official, State Superintendent of Public Instruction, Jill Underly. We’ve been talking about the Department of Public Instruction’s new two-year budget request.
It seeks billions of dollars [00:12:00] in additional state aid for K-12 schools for 2027 to [00:12:30] 2029.