School Information System

Wisconsin DPI adjusted test score reporting to mask declines, state audit finds

Kayla Huynh

  • A state audit found Wisconsin’s Department of Public Instruction prevented some school achievement scores from declining by altering calculations.
  • Auditors determined the DPI failed to include legally required information on school report cards.
  • The DPI replaced declining 2023-24 achievement scores with the previous year’s scores for many schools, obscuring actual performance changes.
  • State Superintendent Jill Underly disputed the audit’s findings, calling the review political and factually incorrect.

The state Department of Public Instruction’s overhaul of how Forward Exam scores were reported kept some schools’ and districts’ report card achievement scores from declining, despite calculations showing the scores otherwise would have fallen, according to a new state audit.

On 2023-24 state report cards, the DPI adjusted achievement scores to account for changes to the Forward Exam and to ensure they wouldn’t fall below the previous year’s scores, the audit said. Auditors also found the DPI failed to meet several legal requirements for reporting school performance data.

The audit examined the DPI’s process in changing the academic standards and testing benchmarks used on school and district report cards. The findings, detailed in a report released Nov. 20 by the nonpartisan Legislative Audit Bureau, could prompt lawmakers to seek new guardrails on how the DPI changes standardized test cut scores.

Republicans on the state Legislature’s audit committee ordered the review in 2025 after the DPI revised how it scored the Forward Exam, a standardized test gauging whether Wisconsin schoolchildren are meeting benchmarks in core subjects. The Forward Exam is among the standardized tests the DPI uses to measure achievement on state report cards, which place schools and districts on a scale from one to five stars, from failing to meet expectations to significantly exceeding them.

———

This is vindication for all of those who suspected something nefarious was happening with the testing standards. These changes to lower the bar weren’t just something that happened: they were to intentionally mislead families about the state of education.

———

Notes and links on the taxpayer funded Wisconsin DPI and Jill Underly.

Share

Fast Lane Literacy™ by sedso

house

Explore teaching tips and learn more about the word house.