School Information System

Civics: Why the National Popular Vote Compact Would Be a Disaster for Wisconsin, and the Country

Maciver:

Democrats now control the governorship and both houses of the Legislature in Wisconsin, Michigan, Pennsylvania, Arizona, and Nevada. Together those five states hold 61 electoral votes. The National Popular Vote Interstate Compact (NPVIC) is already law in 18 states plus Washington, D.C., representing 222 electoral votes. If the five new Democratic trifectas join in 2027, the compact would reach 283 electoral votes, well past the 270 needed to take effect before the 2028 election.

Under the compact, Wisconsin would no longer award its 10 electoral votes to the candidate who wins the most votes in Wisconsin. Instead, our electors would go to whoever wins the most votes nationwide, even if that candidate loses Wisconsin by hundreds of thousands of votes. California, New York, Illinois, and the other large states already in the compact would effectively decide Wisconsin’s electors.

Even one of the intellectual originators of the National Popular Vote idea has publicly called the actual interstate compact a “doomsday machine.” Yale law professor Akhil Amar (who, along with his brother Vikram), helped develop the underlying concept in a 2001 article and has referred to it as “my baby”, used that stark description in a recent interview. The Amars themselves warned early on that there is no true “national popular vote,” because states use different rules for eligibility, registration, absentee voting, recounts, and challenges. The compact papered over those problems, leaving each member state’s election official to cobble together totals from other states under conflicting laws and timelines. Amar’s own characterization underscores the risk of chaos, sabotage, or a constitutional crisis if the compact ever takes effect.

———

Rick Esenberg:

One purpose of the electoral college was to encourage a breadth as well as a depth of support. The founders didn’ want a few heavily populated states do dominate smaller ones. The founders didn’t want a President selected by a popular vote (anything that would establish one requires constitutional amendment.) They didn’t want a President to be selected by Congress. The NPV is anti-constitutional.

Share

Fast Lane Literacy™ by sedso

about

Explore teaching tips and learn more about the word about.