School Information System

College Rankings, Minus the Politics

Wall Street Journal:

A new rating factors in ideological diversity and campus free speech. No. 1? Texas at Austin.

Choosing a college is a daunting task for students and parents, and political polarization hasn’t made it easier. These days a university might get a high ranking for academics and facilities, despite being a hot house of progressive conformity. How are parents supposed to know?

The Manhattan Institute’s publication City Journal aims to fill the information gap, and this week it posted its second annual college ranking, covering 115 name brand schools, public and private. The list is based on 95 variables, including the basics, such as graduation rates and earnings after enrollment. But it also awards points for indicators of ideological diversity, free speech, and emphasis on academic merit rather than identity politics.

Does the college require students to take a class on diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI)? How about a course in U.S. government or history? Is a standardized test score required on applications? Does the school have a “bias reporting system”? How monolithic are faculty campaign donations? Do job ads ask for a DEI statement? Does the school do “land acknowledgments”? The ranking factors in these questions and more, and see its methodology section for details.

The University of Texas at Austin is on top this year, followed by the University of Florida at No. 2. Both have recently set up new “civics schools”—the School of Civic Leadership in Texas and the Hamilton School in Florida—to promote civil discourse and liberal arts in the Western tradition. Rounding out the top five on the City Journal ranking are Notre Dame, MIT and Claremont McKenna.

Share

Fast Lane Literacy™ by sedso

said

Explore teaching tips and learn more about the word said.