School Information System

Nostalgia for No Child Left Behind and Other Education Policy White Elephants

Richard Phelps:

“Evidence is the antidote in education,” writes journalist Holly Korbey in a recent post of her blog, The Bell Ringer. I agree. Still, the skeptic in me asks, “which evidence?” She seemed to answer that question later in the same post: “all the available evidence.”

Well … OK. Does she really mean it? … ALL THE AVAILABLE EVIDENCE?

I have no reason to believe that she wrote insincerely. Nonetheless, I would argue that the answer is no. The paradox turns on what one considers to be “all.”

Read the post through and one discovers that her version of all the evidence confines itself within boundaries. For example, we learn that an “evidence revolution” began only thirty-five years ago, even in the hard sciences and medicine. Before then, “decisions about treatment were often based on ‘someone’s opinion or conventional wisdom.’”

Yet, the Salk polio vaccine I received as a child was not formulated based on opinion and conventional wisdom. Those many thousands of lines of children throughout the country’s schools in the 1950s and 1960s assembled eagerly, but not to be injected with folk belief Before 35 years ago, there were Marie Curie, Antoine Lavoissier, James Faraday, Archimedes, Eratosthenes, and … you get the drift.

Share

Fast Lane Literacy™ by sedso

every

Explore teaching tips and learn more about the word every.