“Having dispensed with democracy, Moyn casts doubt on the concept of property”
Property rights, some anthropologists have proposed, actually originated as “lifesavers for the aged”—something that could allow them protection in a dangerous world in which they were among the weakest physically. The young were superior when it came to fitness and strength; the old lost their natural advantages but succeeded in capturing socially organized surrogate advantages that evened or reversed the imbalance in power. That antediluvian tradition has been modernized in America today.7
If Moyn intends for this passage to have any real implications for policy, rather than just as an excursion into the fanciful, then he is implying something far more radical, and more brutally Darwinian, than anything in Bronze Age Mindset.
The strange thing about Moyn’s radicalism is how selective it is. He tosses the Senate into the dustbin of history, then rushes to clarify that he does not want to cut Medicare. He brings up Daniel Callahan, the bioethicist and author of Setting Limits: Medical Goals in an Aging Society (1987), and compares Callahan’s proposals to limit old people’s medical spending to his own proposals to limit old people’s political power. The difference is that his proposals are “not comparably tragic, outrageous, or even sad,” Moyn writes. “Depriving people of their power, unlike rationing health care, ought to have no bearing on when they die, raising no concerns about totalitarian implications.”8
Medicare and Social Security together are about 40 percent of the federal budget. Health care accounts for more than 18 percent of our gross domestic product. Much of that spending takes place in the last six months of life and is aimed at marginally prolonging the existence of people whose quality of life is low. In what sense is it “totalitarian” to want to cut that massive spending? Is it really more outrageous than monkeying around with fundamental voting rights?