School Information System

First Grade Enrollment is Dropping in Every School Sector

John Johnson

The Milwaukee Public School District is currently considering closing several schools due to declining enrollment. Sometimes, MPS enrollment woes get blamed on the sector wars. Families can choose from a variety of options, and last year the parents of slightly more than half of Milwaukee’s children who receive a publicly funded education chose a school outside the district.

But fundamentally, the most basic reason for MPS’ declining enrollment is not school choice. It is declining birth rates. And these declining birth rates affect schools from every sector—district, charter, voucher, and private pay.

The clearest place to see this is in first grade enrollment. As I’ve written, you can pretty easily predict first grade enrollment in any given year based on the number of kids born six years earlier. Because more young families leave Milwaukee than move into it, first grade enrollment is always less than births six years prior, but the connection between birth rates and subsequent school enrollment is clear, consistent, and inescapable. Milwaukee had 10,400 births in 2010; 8,700 in 2020; and around 7,400 in 2025. That is a drop of 29% in 15 years.

Some schools have closed in the past 15 years, so I wanted to understand how much excess first grade capacity still exists in Milwaukee’s school ecosystem.

No equivalent statistic for building capacity exists across all school sectors, so here is what I measured instead. I identified all of the currently open schools which educated first graders in the 2025-26 school year. There were 197. For each of those schools, I measured the size of their first grade class last year and compared it to the school’s largest first grade class. My enrollment by grade data begins with the 2005-06 school year.

Share

Fast Lane Literacy™ by sedso

dog

Explore teaching tips and learn more about the word dog.