Alas, the Doft Lecture featured only the left-leaning Goldberg, not the more conservative Douthat, so for “vitality” the audience had to settle for Penslar, a liberal, pushing Goldberg with questions. He appeared to be doing his best, but it wasn’t enough to prevent the event from turning into a kind of anti-Trump rally and group therapy session—an strange look for a university that intermittently claims to be recommitting itself to serious scholarship and research and to viewpoint diversity rather than to politicized groupthink.
Where this was headed was clear almost from the start. “I grew up in Buffalo. I got out as soon as I could,” Goldberg said. That condescending comment was greeted by the Harvard audience with appreciative laughter. Compare it with the more gracious way another prominent journalist, Tim Russert, described the same hometown: “I was surrounded by beauty and history and the sense of possibility that a great city instills in its residents. Buffalo captured my imagination and remains a part of me to this day.”
Goldberg described her youth in Buffalo as an activist forming human chains to defend abortion clinics from Operation Rescue protesters who had been invited in, she said, by the city’s Catholic mayor.
“My parents forced me against my will to go to temple, which I absolutely hated,” Goldberg said by way of explaining her Jewish background