Notes on the end of MCAS
As expected, in last month’s election, voters in Massachusetts supported a union-backed ballot initiative to kill off the Bay State’s longstanding graduation exam. At around the same time, New York state officials released a timeline for eliminating the even-longer-standing Regents exams as a requirement for earning a high school diploma. With the number of states requiring students to pass exams in order to graduate now down to the single digits, this feels like the end of an era.
In that spirit, I recently dusted off a (digital) copy of Ready or Not : Creating a High School Diploma That Counts, published by Achieve, The Education Trust, and the Thomas B. Fordham Institute exactly twenty years ago. How far we’ve come—or fallen—since then! At the time, standards-based reformers worried about the eroding value of the high school diploma and wanted to make sure that all students graduated “college and career ready.” (This was meant to supplement the No Child Left Behind act, which brought much-needed accountability to America’s schools, but left studentaccountability on the cutting room floor.)
At the heart of the “American Diploma Project” (ADP) strategy was a set of standards in English language arts and math that strongly influenced the Common Core, which came in 2010, along with the expectation that states would ensure that students met these standards by requiring them to pass exams to prove their mettle.
That was not to be. Soon after the release of the ADP recommendations, Bush Administration officials issued regulations requiring states to incorporate graduation rates, measured in a common way, into their No Child Left Behind accountability systems. The law of unintended consequences kicked in, with the focus shifting from “beefing up the value of the diploma” to “getting everyone across the finish line.” Our national graduation rate went from 79 percent in 2010–11 to 87 percent in 2021–22.
