Madison's Proposed Property Tax Increase: Additional links, notes and emails

I received a kind email from Madison School Board President Ed Hughes earlier today regarding the proposed property tax increase associated with the 2013-2014 District budget.

Ed's email:

Jim --

Your comparison to the tax rates in Middleton is a bit misleading. The Middleton-Cross Plains school district that has a mill rate that is among the lowest in Dane County. I am attaching a table (.xls file) that shows the mill rates for the Dane County school districts. As you will see, Madison's mill rate is lower than the county average, though higher than Middleton's. (Middleton has property value/student that is about 10% higher than Madison, which helps explain the difference.)

The table also includes the expenses/student figures relied upon by DPI for purposes of calculating general state aid for the 2012-13 school year. You may be surprised to see that Madison's per-student expenditures as measured for these purposes is among the lowest in Dane County. Madison's cost/student expenditures went up in the recently-completed school year, for reasons I explain here: http://tinyurl.com/obd2wty

Ed

My followup email:

Hi Ed:

Thanks so much for taking the time to write and sending this along - including your helpful post.

I appreciate and will post this information.

That said, and as you surely know, "mill rate" is just one part of the tax & spending equation:

1. District spending growth driven by new programs, compensation & step increases, infinite campus, student population changes, open enrollment out/in,

2. ongoing "same service" governance, including Fund 80,

3. property tax base changes (see the great recession),

4. exempt properties (an issue in Madison) and

5. growth in other property taxes such as city, county and tech schools.

Homeowners see their "total" property taxes increasing annually, despite declining to flat income. Middleton's 16% positive delta is material and not simply related to the "mill rate".

Further, I continue to be surprised that the budget documents fail to include total spending. How are you evaluating this on a piecemeal basis without the topline number? - a number that seems to change every time a new document is discussed.

Finally, I would not be quite as concerned with the ongoing budget spaghetti if Madison's spending were more typical for many districts along with improved reading results. We seem to be continuing the "same service" approach of spending more than most and delivering sub-par academic results for many students. (Note the recent expert review of the Madison schools Analysis: Madison School District has resources to close achievement gap.)

That is the issue for our community.

Best wishes,

Jim

Related: Middleton-Cross Plains' $91,025,771 2012-2013 approved budget (1.1mb PDF) for 6,577 students, or $13,840.01 per student, roughly 4.7% less than Madison's 2012-2013 spending.

Posted by Jim Zellmer at July 13, 2013 5:47 PM
Subscribe to this site via RSS/Atom: Newsletter signup | Send us your ideas