Former Madison Mayor Critiques Online Education....

Dave Cieslewicz:

But getting back to open courses offered online, here's the problem. It looks a lot like what happened to journalism. As someone has written, "this is what happens when you let English majors run businesses." They gave away the same content they were selling in their papers on the Internet for free. And all that free access to information has resulted in fewer newspapers, fewer professional journalists and, I would say, a poorer public exchange of ideas.

Could the same thing happen in academia? Maybe. The question is this: Why would any cash-strapped family pay north of $40,000 for an education in a bricks and mortar university when world-class knowledge is just a click away for free?

Well, the answer might be that there's no substitute for being on campus -- no substitute for seeing the professor and asking him questions, no substitute for mixing it up with your classmates from around the country and world, no substitute for getting shit-faced and walking home alone along Lake Mendota at midnight on a breezy, balmy early May night and lying on the grass outside Adams Hall, staring up at the stars shining through the old oaks and wondering where your life might take you, not to say anyone I know has done the latter.

Madison should be leading the online learning revolution.

I agree that online learning is not the be all/end all. BUT, it can augment and replace some aspects of traditional education. Again, Madison, with the UW, Edgewood College and MATC should be leading the revolution.

Links: Udacity, MIT Open Courseware, UW online plans and a field guide to online education startups.

Posted by Jim Zellmer at July 3, 2012 2:43 AM
Subscribe to this site via RSS/Atom: Newsletter signup | Send us your ideas