With budgets expected to be tight for the foreseeable future, this means that cuts in other areas – like gifted and talented – are unavoidable, according to John Box, superintendent of the Mequon-Thiensville School District.
Under state law, all Wisconsin districts are required to identify gifted students and give them access to appropriate programs. Robinson and others worry that many districts are no longer complying with the law. Adding to the concerns is the fact that the state Department of Public Instruction has not had a consultant exclusively for gifted education since 1994.
According to the National Association for Gifted Children, Wisconsin is one of only eight states that do not have a state coordinator for gifted programming. It is one of 17 states that did not allocate any money for gifted programming in 2002.
Getting a DPI consultant is “critical,” Clinkenbeard said. Without enforcement from DPI, she said, there’s no way to know how many Wisconsin school districts actually are meeting legal requirements – but she estimates it could be as low as 25%.
According to Clinkenbeard, Wisconsin was recognized as a national leader in gifted education in the 1970s. Its reputation started to decline as teachers retired and weren’t replaced, she said.
“It’s hard to measure what you lose by not challenging them,” said Clinkenbeard, who calls investing in gifted education good for the economy, because it can slow down Wisconsin’s much-publicized brain drain.
Sue Grady, a DPI consultant whose assignment covers gifted and talented among other areas, says the lack of a consultant for gifted and talented does not reflect a lack of commitment. She is involved in plans to hold a summit on gifted education this fall.
Reductions in gifted programming present an equity issue, Robinson said. Affluent families still will be able to give their students enrichment by sending them to camps or special weekend programs. Gifted students from poor families will be able to get the help they need only if it is offered through the public school system, she said