School Information System
Newsletter Sign Up |

Subscribe to this site via RSS: | Newsletter signup | Send us your ideas

July 15, 2013

Other People's Children: Why are white people so eager to advocate for the sort of schools to which they would never send their own children?

edushyster:

Reader: more and more white people agree that strict, "no excuses" style charter schools provide an ideal learning environment for poor minority kids. As proof of this surging enthusiasm I give you exhibit A: a glowing report about Harlem's Democracy Prep charter school featured in the current issue of the New Yorker, one of America's whitest magazines. (Full disclosure: I am white and also a New Yorker subscriber). Which brings us to today's fiercely urgent question: why are white people so eager to advocate for the sort of schools to which they would never send their own children?

Through the Gauntlet
The New Yorker piece, by writer Ian Frazier, is subtitled 'Up Life's Ladder'--but 'gauntlet' might be a more accurate metaphor. Frazier is dazzled by the spectacle of the 44 members of Democracy Prep's first graduating class, on stage at the Apollo Theater in their school-bus-yellow robes, UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon on hand to fete them. But more than three quarters of Democracy Prep's students--23% each year--never made it onto the stage. If Frazier is aware of the school's attrition rate, among the highest in New York City, he doesn't mention it. Nor does Frazier have anything to say about the school's strict "no excuses" disciplinary policy. Instead, he seems excited by the fact that students at the school are required to take Korean, the only foreign language offered. Best of all, Frazier likes the fact that 100% of the remaining graduates are headed to a four-year college.

Posted by Jim Zellmer at July 15, 2013 12:09 AM
Subscribe to this site via RSS/Atom: Newsletter signup | Send us your ideas
Comments
Post a comment









Remember personal info?