School Information System
Newsletter Sign Up |

Subscribe to this site via RSS: | Newsletter signup | Send us your ideas

March 10, 2011

My hard lessons teaching community college

Kate Gieselman:

"Stand up if you have ever been told that you weren't college material," the school president booms during the commencement ceremony.

In answer to his question, dozens of students stand and pump their fists; cheers go up; an air horn blasts. He goes on:

"Now, stand if you are the first member of your family to go to college."

Dozens more rise.

"Stand if you started your degree more than 10 years ago," and then the president tells them to stay standing as he ticks off intervals of time, "Fifteen years? Twenty years? Twenty-five years?"

Posted by Jim Zellmer at March 10, 2011 5:21 AM
Subscribe to this site via RSS/Atom: Newsletter signup | Send us your ideas
Comments

Yes, community colleges are a good option for many students. They may even seem like the only option for some students. For others, the question becomes more complex, and yet simpler too: should "everyone" go to college?

This is a good article. The author does not have all the answers (none of us do), but she does make a lot of good points. I tend to agree with her, for the most part. I also ask what it does to the value of a degree to "help" some students "finish" with untold amounts of support, only to have them graduate unable to do the job they are "trained" for. Would you hire someone with a two-year degree for a job that requires a specific certification, if they finished school because they had hand-holding help the whole time, and still came out with a 2.5 GPA? I know, it depends on the area of specialization. But in many areas (nursing, medical administration, basic accounting, etc.), I bet someone who takes four or more years to graduate with a "two-year" degree, and then barely finishes, is going to have a hard time finding work in that area. And if it isn't to work in that specialization, what was the point of the time and money spent getting the degree.

I think we are kidding ourselves as a country, if we think that "anyone" (or "everyone", if that makes more sense) can retrain (or get their first degree) if they can't find a decent job or if they get laid off. That same mythical "anyone" can then come out of community college or the like (maybe years later) with a degree that will help them get a high-paying, stable career going? Not necessarily. Then again, am I just feeling cynical right now?

Posted by: Millie at March 20, 2011 7:15 PM
Post a comment









Remember personal info?